Árbol de agradecimientos87Gracias

English topic chat

Post-Metal is usually influenced by Punk (specially Post-Hardcore). And Sludge in general is Punk-influenced Metal. That confirms not only that ...

  1. #1981
    Avatar de Vanitas Colaborador/a
    Registrad@ el
    24/09/2013
    Localidad
    El Exilio, Castilla y León
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    145
    Agradecido
    36 veces
    Temas
    6
    Post-Metal is usually influenced by Punk (specially Post-Hardcore). And Sludge in general is Punk-influenced Metal. That confirms not only that your view is limited, but also that you have no idea of what you're saying.

    "
    Empty creature from Ventus riven... to you, the name Vanitas shall be given."


  2. #1982
    Mega Usuari@
    Registrad@ el
    19/10/2006
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    18.133
    Agradecido
    2059 veces
    Temas
    212
    You seem to be angry or something. Maybe you get cranky when the moon is fuuuuuuuuull.


    Being influenced by punk doesnt make it punk. Just like trance isnt progressive even if trance is like an evolution of it.

    My statement said at least oceanos song isnt punk, and thats correct. Just like blink182 isnt punk either but punk-rock.

  3. #1983
    Avatar de Vanitas Colaborador/a
    Registrad@ el
    24/09/2013
    Localidad
    El Exilio, Castilla y León
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    145
    Agradecido
    36 veces
    Temas
    6
    Yes, I'm angry (again) about a comment I can't remember because it was published months ago. The Illuminati, maybe.

    Blink 182 is Punk Pop. So it's Punk and your argument is invalid.

    "Isn't Punk but Punk Rock" LOL. Punk is the genre, Punk Rock, the subgenre. It's like saying Ornette Coleman's The Shape of Jazz to Come is not Jazz because it's Free Jazz. Again, strange views of yours. And they're mostly Pop Punk.
    N_Raist ha agradecido este mensaje.

    "
    Empty creature from Ventus riven... to you, the name Vanitas shall be given."


  4. #1984
    Mega Usuari@
    Registrad@ el
    19/10/2006
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    18.133
    Agradecido
    2059 veces
    Temas
    212
    Ok, I concede that the Blink182 example wasn't good, as indeed they play a subgenre of punk.

    But still you are missing the point. That a given genre may be influenced by punk doesnt make it neither punk nor a subgenre of punk as for that to happen you need punk to be the structural genre where everything else orbit.

    So my initial statement is pretty accurate. Oceanos song may be influenced by punk but it is neither punk nor a subgenre of it.

  5. #1985
    Avatar de Vanitas Colaborador/a
    Registrad@ el
    24/09/2013
    Localidad
    El Exilio, Castilla y León
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    145
    Agradecido
    36 veces
    Temas
    6
    You didn't even know what genre Amen Ra is. Of course is not Punk, but it is widely influenced by it. "At least is not Punk" well, it has things in common, enough to said "this is partially Punk". Aside, "noisy music" came before Punk. Sure you heard about Lou Reed's The Velvet Underground.

    "
    Empty creature from Ventus riven... to you, the name Vanitas shall be given."


  6. #publi
    Publicidad

     

  7. #1986
    Mega Usuari@
    Registrad@ el
    19/10/2006
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    18.133
    Agradecido
    2059 veces
    Temas
    212
    Anyway, you are being a dick. Even if you were right (which you dont) you should be able to undertand that someone who criticizes punk may be having the beef with its purist form.

  8. #1987
    Avatar de Vanitas Colaborador/a
    Registrad@ el
    24/09/2013
    Localidad
    El Exilio, Castilla y León
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    145
    Agradecido
    36 veces
    Temas
    6
    Which you aren't* Don't change the auxiliar verb.

    Of course I'm being a dick. I'd rather be a dick than a swallower.

    I don't know what do you know about Punk. But if you mention Blink 182 and you don't see the obvious Post-Hardcore dynamics in that Amon Ra song, it seems that knowledge is too limited.

    "
    Empty creature from Ventus riven... to you, the name Vanitas shall be given."


  9. #1988
    Mega Usuari@
    Registrad@ el
    19/10/2006
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    18.133
    Agradecido
    2059 veces
    Temas
    212
    Vanitas escribió: Ver mensaje
    You didn't even know what genre Amen Ra is. Of course is not Punk, but it is widely influenced by it. "At least is not Punk" well, it has things in common, enough to said "this is partially Punk". Aside, "noisy music" came before Punk. Sure you heard about Lou Reed's The Velvet Underground.
    Ha! So you finally admit what Oceanos posted wasn't punk. So deep inside you must know that my statement where I claimed "at least it is not punk" was perfectly logical. All the other just bickering. Either you apologize for dragging me into this senseless debate or ill send your ass right to my ignore list (and yep I know you care as otherwise you wouldnt have meant to unfairly correct me in regards to my initial statement about being glad at least oceanos song wasn't punk).
    Última edición hecha por jkhsdjkhsdkj, 29/12/2013 a las 17:02.

  10. #1989
    Avatar de Vanitas Colaborador/a
    Registrad@ el
    24/09/2013
    Localidad
    El Exilio, Castilla y León
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    145
    Agradecido
    36 veces
    Temas
    6
    You can ignore me. That would prove, again, that you are such a cry baby.

    And yes, I care. I care about the last boss in Bravely Default (excellent JRPG I'm playing right now) . What an asshole it is.

    "
    Empty creature from Ventus riven... to you, the name Vanitas shall be given."


  11. #1990
    Mega Usuari@
    Registrad@ el
    19/10/2006
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    18.133
    Agradecido
    2059 veces
    Temas
    212
    Not so, just practical. As automatically closing those windows that pop up when you watch a tv show on Seriesyonkis is being practical as well.

    You were just trying to correct a statement that did not need to be corrected as that song by Amen Ra wasn't punk. Therefore youre just bugging me for the shake of it, just like those pops up Therefore youll be ignored as well.

  12. #1991
    Mega Usuari@
    Registrad@ el
    19/10/2006
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    18.133
    Agradecido
    2059 veces
    Temas
    212
    Btw, since you corrected my grammar contributing for free to my education, let me give you back the favor.

    In Spanish it isnt needed, but in English in this case you need to add the p.pr
    Vanitas escribió: Ver mensaje
    You didn't even know what genre Amen Ra is. Of course is not Punk, but it is widely influenced by it.
    "Of course IT is not punk, but it is blah blah".

    Either that or you need to change the structure of your statement.

    Q

  13. #1992
    Avatar de Vanitas Colaborador/a
    Registrad@ el
    24/09/2013
    Localidad
    El Exilio, Castilla y León
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    145
    Agradecido
    36 veces
    Temas
    6
    Typo error. I was about to write isn't, I made a mistake and, when rephrasing, I didn't write "it". I guess I have an English teacher complex I can't ignore.

    Thank you, anyway. Weren't you going to ignore me?

    "
    Empty creature from Ventus riven... to you, the name Vanitas shall be given."


  14. #1993
    indeed
    Registrad@ el
    08/02/2010
    Sexo
    Chico
    Mensajes
    3.919
    Agradecido
    469 veces
    Temas
    12
    Still 2013 here? shieeet

  15. #1994
    Avatar de Borja Sisante
    Registrad@ el
    26/01/2009
    Localidad
    Sexo
    Chica
    Mensajes
    3.356
    Agradecido
    1098 veces
    Temas
    10
    OCEAN TKM

  16. #1995
    Avatar de Borja Sisante
    Registrad@ el
    26/01/2009
    Localidad
    Sexo
    Chica
    Mensajes
    3.356
    Agradecido
    1098 veces
    Temas
    10
    IM DRUNK, IM PUNK AND I LOVE OCEAN

Permisos de tu Usuario

  • No puedes crear nuevos temas
  • No puedes publicar respuestas
  • No puedes adjuntar archivos
  • No puedes editar tus mensajes
  •  
  • El código BB está activado
  • Los emoticonos están activados
  • La etiqueta [IMG] está activado
  • La etiqueta [VIDEO] está activado
  • El código HTML está activado
  • Los Trackbacks están desactivados
  • Los Pingbacks están desactivados
  • Los Refbacks están activados
  • Temas similares

    1. Respuestas: 519
      Último mensaje: 23/12/2009, 19:38